Advertisement
X

Two-Tier System In Test Cricket: Four Talking Points About Latest Discussion In Traditional Format

Since there has been considerable discussion about the potential inclusion of a two-tier system in Test cricket, let's explore some key talking points on the issue

AP Photo/Mark Baker

The discussion surrounding the potential adoption of the two-tier system in Test cricket has become a significant concern for many lower-ranked teams in recent weeks. But what exactly is this system? How will it function? And is the ICC truly addressing these issues? These are important questions that need to be answered. (More Cricket News)

Following an exciting conclusion to the Border-Gavaskar Trophy series in Australia, cricket authorities noted a significant rise in attendance at stadiums such as the Melbourne Cricket Ground and ꧋the Sydney Cricket Ground. There was also a subs🧸tantial increase in digital viewership for the highly anticipated Best vs Best clash.

Many commentators and cricket experts have called for more series that include major cricketing nations like India, Australia, and England, as this would give the ma༺tches more value and excitement.

All these discussions have led to the idea of a two-tier system in Test cricket, where the top-ranked teams could compete against each other more frequently. This would a🐽llow cricket boards to generate more revenue an🏅d allow fans to enjoy more exciting Test matches.

The International Cricket🦋 Council (ICC) has not yet responded to these matters. However, there are reports that Cricket Australia chairman Mike Baird and England and Wale💞s Cricket Board chairman Richard Thompson are scheduled to meet later this month. One of the topics on the agenda will be the potential inclusion of a two-tier system in Test cricket.

Since there has been consiꩵderable discussion about the potential inclusion of a two-tier system in Test cricket, let's expl💙ore some key talking points on the issue.

1. Profit To Big Cricket Boards

The primary concern regarding the inclusion of the two-tier system in Test cricket is reven♊ue. Lower-ranked teams rely heavily on the income generated from hosting matches against major cricketing nations like Australia, England, or India. For example, if Bangladesh were to stop hosting top-ranked teams, it would struggle to survive financially. They would primarily play against other lower-ranked teams, which may not improve their quality of cricket. While matches like India vs. England or Australia vs. England attract large crowds, the development and growth of emerging cricket nations could be significantly hindered.

2. Promotion And Relegation

The idea of introducing a system of relegation and promotion in Test cricket, similar to European football leagues, raises important questions for the ICC and the World Test Championship (WTC) cycle. Specifically, how many teams will be promoted to the top tier at the end of each WTC cycle, and how many will be relegated? For instance, if India has a poor WTC cycle, can the ICC afford to relegate a major team like India or England? Would the absence of prominent series such as th🦩e Border-Gavaskar Trophy or the Ashes be viable for a WTC cycle?

Advertisement

3. Can India Play Pakistan?

If a two-tier system is introduced in Test cricket, it would require all top-ran🔯ked teams to compete against each other at least once during each World Test Championship (WTC) cycle. This could provide India and Pakistan with an opportunity to play their first Test match against each other since 2007. The question then arises: Can the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) permit a series against Pakistan, and if so, where would it be held?

4. Difficulty For Emerging Nations

The primary goal of the ICC is to promote cricket and enhance its quality in as many nations as possible. While revenue is essential for supporting such 💟a vast sport, is it the only thing needed at this moment? If nations like Afghanistan, the West Indies, Bangladesh, and Zimbabwe are not allow🐈ed to compete against established teams like England, Australia, and New Zealand, how will their cricket develop? How can they improve their standards, and how can emerging nations like Uganda or the UAE gain entry into the Test structure?

Advertisement

Recently, Bangladesh achieved a notable victory against Pakistan at home, and the West Indies triumphed over Australia i꧙n a Pink Ball Test when Shamar Joseph gained prominence. These significant changes in Test cricket among the so-called lower-ranked teams indicate progress. Therefore, if a two-tier system is introduced at this stage, it could hinder their development.

Show comments
SG